jingchen

注册日期:2015-11-11
访问总量:3798970次

menu网络日志正文menu

Soldner’s 1801 paper on light bending


发表时间:+-

Soldner’s 1801 paper on light bending by gravitational force


Few people could even imagine light can be bent by gravitational force. It took the unique genius of Einstein to achieve that. The story goes. But like many other legendary stories about prominent people, this story is also false. The idea of light bending by gravitational force was once pretty common.

Soldner, in 1801, calculated the bending of light when it passes through a gravitational field. The method is identical to the calculation of trajectory of any object passing through a gravitational field. He even calculated the condition when light cannot escape the gravitational pull. This is identical to the situation when planets, such as Earth, cannot escape the gravitational pull of the sun. In this way, he predicted the condition of blackhole.

The simplicity of his method is remarkable. Soldner is truly a great genius. However, “only sporadic and at times misleading references have been made to Johann Georg von Soldner”.

An introduction of Soldner’s life and work can be found from the following paper. In this paper, the history of ideas of light bending and variable speed of light is also discussed.

 

Jaki, S.L. (1978) Johann Georg von Soldner and the gravitational bending of light, with an English translation of his essay on it published in 1801. Found Phys 8, 927–950.

Some quotations from the paper.

To this technical conclusion, which in Lihotzky's eyes was damaging, though not fatally, to Einstein's theory, he added a philosophical conclusion which covertly endorsed the charge that relativity rested on complex assumptions bordering on contradictions. The truth of a theory, Lihotzky claimed, ultimately rested on its being free of contradictions: "if it makes a number of existing contradictions to disappear without introducing new ones then we must attribute to it a greater content of truth.  (P 931)

Comment: The logical inconsistency of the relativity theory is a big problem.

The other aspect is his rigorous insistence on the mechanical character of all processes. It was that rigor which made him postulate the variability of the speed of light and its being subject to gravitational attraction, just as any other material phenomenon and entity was subject to it. His pondering of such ideas could naturally raise in his mind the idea of the bending of light in strong gravitational fields and make him search for a method of determining it with accuracy. (P 937)

In Einstein's popular accounts of relativity Soldner is never mentioned. (P 937)

 


浏览(1169)
thumb_up(0)
评论(14)
  • 当前共有14条评论
  • jingchen

    A good site on physics: Dr Jorge Diaz

    https://youtube.com/@jkzero?si=1glyITPDFg_qe-MU

    屏蔽 举报回复
  • jingchen
    Soldner’s 1801 paper on light bending by gravity

    Few people could even imagine light can be bent by gravity. It took the unique genius of Einstein to achieve that. The story goes. But like many other legendary stories about prominent people, this story is also false. The idea of light bending by gravity was once pretty common.

    There are two main theories about light, wave theory and particle theory. With particle theory, it is easy to imagine light, as particles, being attracted and bent by gravity. Newton had talked about it. Laplace had talked about it.  Soldner, in 1801, made a detailed calculation on the bending of light when it passes through a gravitational field.

    Soldner’s method is identical to the calculation of trajectory of any particle passing through a gravitational field. He calculated the amount of bending of light when it passes by the earth and the sun. He even calculated the strength of gravity when light cannot escape the gravitational pull. This is identical to the situation when planets, such as Earth, cannot escape the gravitational pull of the sun. With this calculation, he predicted the condition of blackhole.

    The simplicity of his method is remarkable. Soldner’s calculation preceded Einstein’s calculation by more than one hundred years. However, “only sporadic and at times misleading references have been made to Johann Georg von Soldner” [1]. “In Einstein's popular accounts of relativity Soldner is never mentioned.” [1]

    From reading Soldner’s single paper, we learned that it was really natural to conceive the idea of light bending by gravity, it is really easy to understand black holes.  

    From reading the vast amount of literature on general relativity and vast amount of popular writings on general relativity, we learned that it takes Einstein to conceive the idea of light bending by gravity, it is magical to even think about black holes.  

    When a problem can only be solved by an extremely complex process, the problem solver is perceived as a genius. When the same problem can be solved by a simple method as well, the problem is perceived as trivial and the problem solvers are perceived as trivial. To maintain the image of a genius, the vast machinery has to suppress the knowledge of a simple solution.

    References: 

    1.        Jaki, S.L. (1978) Johann Georg von Soldner and the gravitational bending of light, with an English translation of his essay on it published in 1801. Found Phys 8, 927–950.

    2. Mignonat, M., 2018. Soldner had found in 1802 the deflection of the light by the sun as the general relativity shows. Journal of Modern Physics, 9(8), pp.1545-1558.

     

    屏蔽 举报回复
  • jingchen

    How GPS works

    https://youtu.be/qJ7ZAUjsycY?si=pA-1yGleNFCQxZzU

    屏蔽 举报回复
  • jingchen

    How GPS works

    https://youtu.be/qJ7ZAUjsycY?si=pA-1yGleNFCQxZzU

    屏蔽 举报回复
  • jingchen

    How GPS works

    https://youtu.be/qJ7ZAUjsycY?si=pA-1yGleNFCQxZzU

    屏蔽 举报回复
  • jingchen

    How GPS works

    https://youtu.be/qJ7ZAUjsycY?si=pA-1yGleNFCQxZzU

    屏蔽 举报回复
  • jingchen

    How GPS works

    https://youtu.be/qJ7ZAUjsycY?si=pA-1yGleNFCQxZzU

    屏蔽 举报回复
  • jingchen

    How GPS works

    https://youtu.be/qJ7ZAUjsycY?si=pA-1yGleNFCQxZzU

    屏蔽 举报回复
  • jingchen

    How GPS works

    https://youtu.be/qJ7ZAUjsycY?si=pA-1yGleNFCQxZzU

    屏蔽 举报回复
  • jingchen

    How GPS works

    https://youtu.be/qJ7ZAUjsycY?si=pA-1yGleNFCQxZzU

    屏蔽 举报回复